-
Perspectives - Six Opportunities to Improve Understanding of Fuel Treatment Longevity in Historically Frequent-Fire Forests
This paper addresses the critical need for improved understanding of the long-term effectiveness of fuel reduction treatments in dry, fire-prone forests of western North America. The authors highlight that current knowledge limitations lead to ineffi...This paper addresses the critical need for improved understanding of the long-term effectiveness of fuel reduction treatments in dry, fire-prone forests of western North America. The authors highlight that current knowledge limitations lead to inefficient maintenance and inaccurate wildfire forecasting. They propose six key research opportunities designed to refine our grasp of how long treatments remain effective. These opportunities include evaluating longevity within specific management goals, referencing desired ecological conditions, accounting for natural forest variability, exploring internal treatment factors, increasing post-treatment sampling frequency, and incorporating spatial heterogeneity into analyses. The paper aims to foster climate-adaptive management that enhances dry forest resilience to wildfire through more efficient and informed treatment strategies. -
Fire Treatment Effects on Vegetation, Structure, Fuels, and Potential Fire Severity in Western U.S. Forests
This paper investigates the effectiveness of various fire management treatments on western U. S. coniferous forests, which have become more susceptible to severe wildfires due to a century of fire exclusion and altered land use. Researchers analyzed ...This paper investigates the effectiveness of various fire management treatments on western U. S. coniferous forests, which have become more susceptible to severe wildfires due to a century of fire exclusion and altered land use. Researchers analyzed the impacts of mechanical thinning, prescribed burning, and a combination of both across six diverse sites. The study found that mechanical thinning combined with prescribed fire was the most effective strategy for significantly reducing surface fuel loads, decreasing the likelihood of severe crown fires, and lowering predicted tree mortality. While mechanical-only treatments were less consistent, they were effective when whole-tree harvesting systems were used, minimizing residual surface fuels. -
Direct Seeding in Reforestation - A Field Performance Review
This document focuses on direct seeding as a reforestation method, offering a comprehensive analysis of its historical context, current efficacy, and future potential. The authors detail the merits of direct seeding, highlighting its ecological advan...This document focuses on direct seeding as a reforestation method, offering a comprehensive analysis of its historical context, current efficacy, and future potential. The authors detail the merits of direct seeding, highlighting its ecological advantages, natural root system development, cost-effectiveness compared to planting seedlings, and operational benefits for large, remote, or low-budget restoration projects. Despite these advantages, the review examines current research findings which consistently show low seedling establishment rates due to various limiting factors such as seed parameters, timing of seeding, inappropriate seeding practices, unfavorable microsite conditions, competitive vegetation, and significant seed predation. The document also provides a direct comparison between seeding and traditional seedling planting, generally concluding that planted seedlings exhibit higher survival and faster initial growth. Finally, it explores potential alternative direct seeding practices and technologies, like seed shelters and drone-based delivery systems, that aim to overcome existing challenges and enhance the success rates of this method for global forest restoration efforts. -
To Masticate or Not - Useful Tips for Treating Forest Woodland and Shrubland Vegetation
This document serves as a comprehensive guide for land managers considering mastication as a vegetation management tool. It synthesizes current scientific knowledge, detailing the characteristics and costs of various mastication equipment, including ...This document serves as a comprehensive guide for land managers considering mastication as a vegetation management tool. It synthesizes current scientific knowledge, detailing the characteristics and costs of various mastication equipment, including carrier machines and cutting heads. The report also summarizes the ecological effects of mastication on vegetation, soils, and wildlife habitat, noting the variability of these impacts across different ecosystems. It provides decision trees and implementation criteria to aid managers in selecting the most appropriate treatment methods and mastication configurations based on their specific site conditions and management objectives. -
Mitigating Old Tree Mortality in Long-Unburned Fire-Dependent Forests - A Synthesis
This report addresses the critical issue of maintaining large, old trees in United States forests that historically experienced frequent fires but have been subjected to long periods of fire suppression. The document synthesizes existing research to ...This report addresses the critical issue of maintaining large, old trees in United States forests that historically experienced frequent fires but have been subjected to long periods of fire suppression. The document synthesizes existing research to understand how reintroducing fire through prescribed burning impacts these venerable trees, particularly concerning injury and mortality. It delves into the causes of tree death from fire, including heat damage to crowns, cambium, and roots, with a specific focus on the role of accumulated duff and subsequent bark beetle attacks. Furthermore, the report examines management options and treatment effects aimed at enhancing old tree resilience during prescribed burns, offering practical guidance on techniques like duff raking and burning under specific conditions, ultimately striving to balance ecological restoration with the conservation of these keystone forest components. -
Operational Resilience in Western US Frequent-Fire Forests
This paper explores operational resilience in western U. S. frequent-fire forests, emphasizing how historical forest structures fostered health and adaptability. The authors argue that very low tree densities prior to widespread fire suppression mini...This paper explores operational resilience in western U. S. frequent-fire forests, emphasizing how historical forest structures fostered health and adaptability. The authors argue that very low tree densities prior to widespread fire suppression minimized competition, which in turn supported vigorous tree growth and greater resistance to stressors like drought and bark beetles. By comparing historical data with contemporary forest conditions using the Stand Density Index, the authors found a significant increase in tree density and competition today. This sugests that current management practices, which are focused primarily on fuel reduction, may not adequately restore the ecological resilience historically maintained by frequent, low-intensity fires. The paper advocates for a fundamental rethinking of forest management to prioritize significantly lower tree densities and minimal competition to enhance long-term forest health. -
Growing-Space Management in Boreal Mixedwood Forests
This document introduces a field study in British Columbia designed to move away from creating forest monocultures and toward sustainable mixedwood management. The text contrasts traditional unmixing practices with a new experimental project that te...This document introduces a field study in British Columbia designed to move away from creating forest monocultures and toward sustainable mixedwood management. The text contrasts traditional unmixing practices with a new experimental project that tests alternative brushing treatments, such as manual cutting and localized chemical applications. By comparing six different methods across established plots, the authors aim to determine how to best promote white spruce growth while maintaining the ecological and economic benefits provided by trembling aspen. This document serves as an early record of the site's characteristics and the long-term research objectives required to balance timber yields with biodiversity and ecosystem stability in the boreal forest. -
Silvicultural Options for Young Growth Douglas-Fir Forests - the Capitol Forest Study Establishment and First Results
This document summarizes the early findings of a multidisciplinary study in Washington's Capitol Forest, which evaluates six different silvicultural regimes ranging from traditional clearcutting to group selection and untreated controls on an operati...This document summarizes the early findings of a multidisciplinary study in Washington's Capitol Forest, which evaluates six different silvicultural regimes ranging from traditional clearcutting to group selection and untreated controls on an operational scale. By managing young-growth Douglas-fir stands for multiple objectives, researchers aim to provide forest managers with quantitative data on the biological, financial, and social consequences of various timber harvest patterns. Key themes include the comparative costs and feasibility of implementing these systems, the physical impact on soil and regeneration, and the public's aesthetic response to different landscape conditions. This study seeks to identify management options that can sustain high timber yields while simultaneously enhancing wildlife habitat and visual appeal to meet modern societal expectations. -
Assessing Post-Fire Douglas-fir Mortality and Douglas-fir Beetle Attacks in the Northern Rocky Mountains
This report presents models to predict the likelihood of Douglas-fir mortality and bark beetle infestation following wildfires. The authors developed these tools using data from past fires in Montana and Wyoming, aiming to improve both pre-fire plann...This report presents models to predict the likelihood of Douglas-fir mortality and bark beetle infestation following wildfires. The authors developed these tools using data from past fires in Montana and Wyoming, aiming to improve both pre-fire planning and post-fire management decisions. The report details the significant variables influencing tree survival and beetle attacks, such as crown scorch and cambium damage, and includes a supplementary field guide with visual aids and methods for field data collection, providing a practical resource for forest managers. -
Fuel Treatment Efficacy in Fire-Prone Forests of Interior British Columbia, Canada
This document investigates the effectiveness of various thinning, pruning, and residue fuel management strategies designed to mitigate extreme wildfire hazards in the fire-prone forests of interior British Columbia. Using both simulated scenarios and...This document investigates the effectiveness of various thinning, pruning, and residue fuel management strategies designed to mitigate extreme wildfire hazards in the fire-prone forests of interior British Columbia. Using both simulated scenarios and analyses of actual operational treatments, the research modeled impacts on passive and active crown fire potential, as well as tree mortality. A key finding is that while removing small trees reduces the risk of passive crown fire, the concurrent removal of some larger trees is necessary to substantially reduce the threat of active crown fire. The study also confirmed that effective management of residue fuels is critical for treatment success, while pruning was found to have minimal impact on crown fire mitigation. This work provides valuable, region-specific data to help forest managers make informed wildfire management decisions regarding necessary treatment intensity. -
Braiding Indigenous and Western Knowledge for Climate Adapted Forests - An Ecocultural State of Science Report
This document outlines the critical need to braid Indigenous Knowledge and Western Science to create climate-adapted forests in the United States. A primary theme is the historical impact of Euro-American colonization, fire exclusion, and settler c...This document outlines the critical need to braid Indigenous Knowledge and Western Science to create climate-adapted forests in the United States. A primary theme is the historical impact of Euro-American colonization, fire exclusion, and settler colonialism on North American forest ecosystems, leading to the loss of Indigenous stewardship and creating dense, fire-maladapted landscapes highly vulnerable to severe wildfires and climate change stressors. The text defines IK as an invaluable, multi-generational body of systemic knowledge and cultural practices emphasizing kinship with nature and reciprocity, contrasting it with the empirical and objective approach of WS. -
Silviculture Strategies to Support Mature and Old-Growth Forest Conditions Across Diverse Ownerships
This webinar explores silvicultural options for managing for mature and old-growth forest conditions across a range of forest and ownership types in the US. The consistency of these strategies with other objectives and programs tied to biodiversity c...This webinar explores silvicultural options for managing for mature and old-growth forest conditions across a range of forest and ownership types in the US. The consistency of these strategies with other objectives and programs tied to biodiversity conservation, climate mitigation, and forest adaptation are discussed. -
Retaining Old Trees When Re-Introducing Fire into Long-Burning Forests That Historically Burned Frequently
This document synthesizes existing knowledge on reintroducing fire into long-unburned, fire-dependent forests of the United States, specifically focusing on how to minimize mortality of large, old trees. Historically, these ecosystems experienced fre...This document synthesizes existing knowledge on reintroducing fire into long-unburned, fire-dependent forests of the United States, specifically focusing on how to minimize mortality of large, old trees. Historically, these ecosystems experienced frequent, low-intensity fires, which kept fuel loads low and fostered fire-tolerant species. However, over a century of fire suppression has led to unprecedented accumulations of deep duff and increased tree densities, making reintroducing fire a complex challenge that can paradoxically harm the very old trees practitioners aim to protect. The document delves into causes of tree injury and mortality from fire, such as basal cambium damage from smoldering duff and subsequent bark beetle attacks, and explores various management options including prescribed burning with the aim of restoring historical forest conditions and preserving venerable trees. -
Slash Burning for Site Preparation
This webinar outlines a successful ten-year effort to refine reforestation techniques using post-harvest slash burning in Minnesota after a large-scale jack pine budworm salvage operation. While initial attempts tried to use fire and direct seeding f...This webinar outlines a successful ten-year effort to refine reforestation techniques using post-harvest slash burning in Minnesota after a large-scale jack pine budworm salvage operation. While initial attempts tried to use fire and direct seeding for complete restoration, the team discovered that the prescribed burns were most effective when used as a tool for controlling aggressive woody competition like aspen. Experience taught the team that achieving deep root-kill and effective brush control depends on conducting burns during late summer dry soil conditions, which is crucial for maximizing intensity. The resulting methodology integrates fire as a hybrid replacement for chemical herbicide application, successfully preparing sites for planting and promoting the establishment of diverse jack pine stands. -
Operationalizing Adaptive Silviculture for Climate Change
This webinar discusses operationalizing adaptive silviculture for climate change through a multi-site research network. The core purpose of the project is to provide forest managers with real-world, operational examples of integrating climate change ...This webinar discusses operationalizing adaptive silviculture for climate change through a multi-site research network. The core purpose of the project is to provide forest managers with real-world, operational examples of integrating climate change adaptation principles into practice, specifically by fostering ecosystem resilience to uncertain futures. The research employs a consistent framework across various forest types, testing three primary adaptation strategies including resistance, resilience, and transition. The webinar details the work at the Minnesota pine site, highlighting local climate vulnerability to drought and the application of these three treatments: simple thinning for resistance, mixed-species restoration for resilience, and aggressive transition management using both native and novel, future-adapted species like Ponderosa pine. -
Adaptive Silviculture for Climate Change - Lessons for Timber-Oriented Managers
This webinar focused on adapting timber management practices to environmental shifts. The webinar establishes the urgent need for adaptation by detailing regional climate projections, including rising temperatures and increased summer drought frequen...This webinar focused on adapting timber management practices to environmental shifts. The webinar establishes the urgent need for adaptation by detailing regional climate projections, including rising temperatures and increased summer drought frequency, which pose significant threats to traditionally managed commercial species like Red Pine. The framework consisting of Resistance, Resilience, and Transition strategies is introduced, demonstrating how varying levels of silvicultural intervention, from thinning to mitigate drought to planting novel species via assisted migration, can reduce climate vulnerability. The central purpose of the discussion is to convince land managers that they can implement these science-backed silvicultural actions to sustain forest productivity and commercial value despite increasing ecological risks. -
Biochar in the Forest - Status Update
This webianr explored the use of biochar as a promising but highly variable soil amendment intended to enhance forest climate resilience, focusing on its potential for increased water holding capacity and long-term carbon storage. Lead researcher, Ma...This webianr explored the use of biochar as a promising but highly variable soil amendment intended to enhance forest climate resilience, focusing on its potential for increased water holding capacity and long-term carbon storage. Lead researcher, Marcelo Windmuller-Campione, detailed multiple collaborative studies, primarily testing biochara?Ts effectiveness on Jack Pine survival and growth in Minnesota's porous, sandy soils. While initial benefits were sometimes observed in early field trials, long-term data and controlled experiments indicated that the biochar provided no significant or lasting improvement compared to control groups. The research concluded that while biochar presents a viable carbon storage strategy, its operational feasibility and ecological benefits are severely limited when applied to highly porous forest ecosystems. -
Silvicultural Systems
This webinar details the core concepts of silvicultural systems, which are comprehensive approaches to forest management defined by three continuous elements: regeneration, tending, and harvesting. These systems are structured along a practical spect...This webinar details the core concepts of silvicultural systems, which are comprehensive approaches to forest management defined by three continuous elements: regeneration, tending, and harvesting. These systems are structured along a practical spectrum of harvest intensity, starting with low-disturbance selection methods suitable for shade-tolerant species and culminating in high-intensity treatments like clearcutting, which favor light-demanding species. The choice of technique, such as the multi-step shelterwood method or the more localized seed tree method, depends entirely on the desired future condition of the stand and the ecology of the target tree species. Successful silviculture is presented as both a science and an art, requiring creative application of various treatments, including intermediate thinning, to achieve specific outcomes. -
Technical Guidance for Standardized Silvicultural Prescriptions for Managing Old-Growth Forests
This guidance document establishes a Standard Silvicultural Prescription Process for the conservation and stewardship of old-growth forests on National Forest System lands. Its fundamental objective is to provide detailed direction for maintaining or...This guidance document establishes a Standard Silvicultural Prescription Process for the conservation and stewardship of old-growth forests on National Forest System lands. Its fundamental objective is to provide detailed direction for maintaining or restoring the ecological integrity and resilience of these valuable ecosystems against threats like wildfire, insects, and climate change, emphasizing that treatments should not be driven by economic reasons. The structured approach involves five key phases, starting with a rigorous stand examination and diagnosis to determine treatment needs, which prioritize less intensive methods such as prescribed fire and thinning. This guidance ensures that management activities are monitored and evaluated to enhance the durability, resilience, and resistance of existing old-growth forest conditions. -
Fuel Treatments in Whitebark Pine Forests - Limiting Whitebark Pine Mortality During Burning
This document provides guidance on using fuel treatments and prescribed burning to protect whitebark pine forests, emphasizing methods to mitigate WBP mortality during fire. It outlines specific thresholds for crown and bark char damage that threate...This document provides guidance on using fuel treatments and prescribed burning to protect whitebark pine forests, emphasizing methods to mitigate WBP mortality during fire. It outlines specific thresholds for crown and bark char damage that threaten tree survival and suggests that mechanical treatments may be necessary to reduce fuels prior to burning, particularly in areas with abundant competing conifers. The document categorizes forest stands as Good, Marginal, or Avoid Candidate Areas for prescribed burning based on the presence of cone-bearing WBP trees and vigorous regeneration, advocating for mechanical fuel reduction in high-value areas and generally advising against burning stands with high levels of cone-bearing trees or limited competition. Finally, the paper recommends coordinating fire planning with silviculturists and entomologists to account for factors like mountain pine beetle pressure and ensure a heterogeneous forest structure that minimizes the risk of large, high-severity wildfires.