58 resources found

This technical report details the outcomes of the Montane Alternative Silvicultural Systems study, which was prompted by operational concerns about forest regeneration and public pressure to limit clearcutting in high-elevation coastal regions of British Columbia. The core objective was to compare the operational productivity and financial viability of three alternative harvesting techniques including uniform shelterwood, green tree retention, and patch cutting against a conventional clearcut. The findings indicated that while these innovative systems could be applied successfully on gentle terrain, they resulted in significantly higher harvesting costs, with the shelterwood system proving to be 38% more expensive than clearcutting. The report also examined the acceptable low levels of site disturbance and soil compaction caused by the machinery, confirming that long-term success will rely on future monitoring of windthrow occurrence and regeneration success.

The Montane Alternative Silvicultural Systems trial was designed to compare the ecological effects of traditional clearcutting against alternative silvicultural systems regarding forest nutrient dynamics in coastal British Columbia. Researchers observed that while harvesting led to a slight, short-lived increase in soil nitrogen availability, the resulting fluxes of nitrogen below the rooting zone were negligible. A key finding was that mineralized nitrogen remained predominantly in the form of ammonium, and subsequent nitrate increases were primarily due to decreased microbial consumption rather than increased production. The study concluded that since the estimated nitrogen losses from the rooting zone were minimal compared to vast soil reserves and natural atmospheric inputs, harvesting is unlikely to negatively impact future site productivity.

This research documents a six-year monitoring study at the Montane Alternative Silvicultural Systems site, examining how different harvesting methods influence the likelihood of windthrow damage in coastal montane forests. The study quantified stem loss across four treatments, including clearcut, shelterwood, green tree retention, and patch cut, finding that windthrow losses were substantial across the site, which was not initially considered high risk. Although low-density green tree retention experienced the highest proportion of damaged trees, the overall greatest number of wind-damaged stems occurred in the shelterwood treatment. The data indicates that small, concentrated patch cuts resulted in the lowest amount of windthrow, suggesting that grouped retention is a more effective strategy than dispersed retention for minimizing wind damage. The authors conclude that adopting group retention strategies can better conserve structural forest elements while addressing challenges related to windthrow risk.

This document on the 26-year assessment of the Montane Alternative Silvicultural Systems evaluates the success of planted Amabilis fir and Western Hemlock seedlings established in 1994. The core purpose of the MASS study is to measure the impact of four distinct establishment treatments, including control, fertilization, herbicide, or a combination, on tree growth over time. These treated plots are systematically mapped within the context of various silvicultural harvesting systems, including clearcut, green tree, patch cut, and shelterwood. The images act as an inventory, identifying the specific plot numbers selected for the 2019 photographic evaluation of the long-term experimental outcomes within each system.

This document on the 26-year assessment of the Montane Alternative Silvicultural Systems study focuses on natural regeneration and understory species within various managed forest environments. The MASS study is highly structured, comparing distinct silvicultural systems such as clearcut, shelterwood, and old growth by utilizing three separate replicates for each treatment type. Data collection relies on establishing Permanent Vegetation Plots, which incorporate smaller, precisely defined nested sub-plots to monitor detailed plant life, including herbs, bryophytes, and tagged conifer species like Amabilis fir and Western Hemlock. These images function as a structured index, associating specific plot and photo numbers with each experimental manipulation across the research site.

This comprehensive 15-year report details the Montane Alternative Silvicultural Systems Project, which tested the efficacy of different harvesting treatments, including clearcutting, patch cutting, and various forms of retention, on forest health and regeneration in coastal British Columbia. Key findings reveal that while conifer survival remained consistent across treatments, tree height and volume growth was generally slower in the shelterwood environment due to reduced light, and the single most effective way to boost planted tree growth was through intensive vegetation control. Conversely, the shelterwood system successfully maintained the greatest understory species diversity and composition most similar to the uncut old-growth forest, minimizing the loss of shade-loving plants. The long-term data emphasizes a crucial trade-off: maximizing early conifer growth favors more open treatments, but retaining pre-harvest biodiversity values is best achieved with substantial canopy protection.

The Montane Alternative Silvicultural Systems project is a 25-year study designed to evaluate how different harvesting methods impact regeneration, wildlife habitat, and aesthetics at high elevations on Vancouver Island. This research compared standard clearcutting with three alternative silvicultural systems including patch cut, green tree, and shelterwood, while tracking the growth and survival of five conifer species. The findings revealed that planted Douglas-fir was the fastest growing species across all treatments, despite experiencing the highest rate of mortality. The research also confirmed that post-planting efforts such as vegetation control significantly improved the volume and growth of species like western hemlock and amabilis fir over the long term.

This study, conducted at the Montane Alternative Silvicultural Systems site, investigated the phenomenon of growth check in young amabilis fir trees, characterized by a sharp decline in annual height increment approximately ten years after planting. Researchers hypothesized that this severe growth limitation was linked to aggressive competition from ericaceous shrubs, such as Vaccinium species, resulting in limited nutrient availability, particularly nitrogen deficiency. By comparing different harvest treatments and the use of early herbicide treatment, the study concluded that vegetation control was the most significant factor in maintaining growth - trees without herbicide were often severely stunted and exhibited greater Vaccinium cover. The findings establish that high shrub competition coupled with low foliar nitrogen are reliable indicators for diagnosing and predicting this critical growth failure on coastal montane sites.

This report outlines the Montane Alternative Silvicultural Systems study, a large-scale project designed to test the ecological and operational feasibility of harvest methods beyond conventional clearcutting in coastal British Columbia montane forests. The research examined the biological and silvicultural impacts of four systems, including clearcut, patch cuts, green tree retention, and shelterwood, to address concerns regarding regeneration, aesthetics, and biodiversity in challenging high-elevation environments. Key findings indicated that while clearcutting was often the most cost-effective, alternative systems faced specific issues, such as increased operational costs and shade limitations that suppressed seedling growth in the shelterwood treatments. The results offer actionable implications, suggesting that small patch cuts and low retention levels can be successfully implemented without significantly reducing early plantation performance.

This study aimed to identify viable silvicultural alternatives to conventional clearcutting for promoting successful forest renewal in black spruce stands across the eastern Canadian boreal zone. Researchers evaluated whether partial harvesting techniques, specifically variations of shelterwood and seed-tree cutting, could achieve adequate conifer density over a ten-year period. The results confirmed that these partial harvest methods, when implemented alongside mechanical site preparation such as spot scarification, successfully facilitated sufficient density of black spruce regeneration. The research supports the use of shelterwood and seed-tree systems combined with soil disturbance as effective management strategies for meeting sustainable forest productivity objectives.

This document summarizes the findings of the Montane Alternative Silvicultural Systems study, detailing a long-term comparison of how different harvesting techniques affect the survival and growth of western redcedar and yellow cedar. The study contrasted methods such as clearcut, shelterwood, and various retention systems over a 28-year period to assess key metrics like height and volume at the 25-year mark. The conclusions revealed that the silvicultural system profoundly impacts growth rates, showing that western redcedar grew fastest in clearcuts while yellow cedar achieved greater volume and height in the shaded shelterwood environments. This indicates distinct species preferences regarding light exposure following logging.

This paper examines ecosystem management strategies for the paludified boreal forests of Canada, emphasizing how to simultaneously enhance wood production, biodiversity, and carbon sequestration. The authors delve into how natural disturbances, particularly fire severity, influence forest dynamics, soil properties, and the diversity of plant and invertebrate communities. They then contrast these natural processes with the impacts of different logging methods on soil, productivity, and understory vegetation, highlighting how traditional clearcutting and careful logging compare to natural fire regimes. Finally, the paper discusses the critical role of these forests in carbon sequestration and proposes management approaches that emulate natural disturbances to maintain old-growth forest characteristics and mitigate climate change.

This study investigates the factors influencing natural regeneration in uniform shelterwood systems, specifically focusing on Douglas-fir in the Sub-Boreal Spruce Zone. The study details methods for assessing seedfall density, seed predation, seedbed distribution, and the germination and survival rates of seedlings under various harvesting treatments. The core purpose is to understand how these elements interact to determine successful conifer regeneration, particularly noting that rotting wood and mineral soil are superior seedbeds compared to forest floor and moss, and that while harvesting can increase mineral soil exposure, it is often insufficient to maximize regeneration without additional scarification. The findings suggest that while all tested shelterwood methods promote adequate regeneration and frost protection, lower residual basal areas combined with significant forest floor disturbance are most favorable for Douglas-fir seedling growth and survival.

This paper investigates innovative harvesting and silvicultural systems designed to sustainably manage western Canada's boreal mixedwood forests, specifically focusing on the protection of immature white spruce while simultaneously enhancing deciduous regeneration. The studies were conducted in central and northern Alberta with the aim to develop cost-effective and operational methods for balancing the needs of conifer and deciduous users to maintain biodiversity and ecosystem sustainability. Key findings include the demonstration that specific equipment and techniques can significantly reduce damage to spruce during harvest, with particular emphasis on feller-buncher operations, carefully planned machine corridors, and wind buffers to mitigate blowdown.

This technical report explores silvicultural systems for managing deciduous and mixedwood stands that contain a white spruce understory in southwestern Alberta. The primary purpose of the document is to explain different management options and harvesting techniques that protect this understory, particularly focusing on a two-stage harvesting model for sustainable production of both conifer and hardwood. It emphasizes evaluating stand suitability, site conditions, and wind damage risk to ensure successful regeneration and growth of spruce and aspen and addresses the complexities of balancing timber yield with ecosystem health and biodiversity.

This document investigates harvesting small patch clearcuts in southeastern British Columbia. Faced with the challenge of balancing timber extraction with high recreational values and visually sensitive landscapes, this study aims to evaluate different harvesting systems. The study was conducted at Robson Ridge and Pilot Point and compared the productivity, costs, and site disturbance of ground-skidding and cable-yarding methods, highlighting key factors like terrain, machine type, and operational planning that influence the success of these silvicultural approaches in visually sensitive areas. The findings emphasize that meticulous planning, especially concerning road layouts and patch boundaries, is crucial for achieving both economic and environmental objectives in small patch clearcutting.

This report details a collaborative study evaluating different timber harvesting methods in dry Douglas-fir ecosystems. The primary goal was to compare the productivity of clearcutting with various variable retention treatments (seed-tree, regeneration cut, removal cut), utilizing both cable-yarding and ground-skidding systems. The study also aimed to identify operational factors affecting varibale retention efficiency and to validate procedures for these systems, noting that factors like piece size, slope, and yarding/skidding distance often overshadowed the cutting pattern's influence on productivity.

This document reports on a government initiative, the Silvicultural Systems Program, established in response to public criticism of widespread clearcutting in British Columbia's forests starting in 1990. The paper describes the program's goal of exploring and demonstrating diverse forest harvesting practices through numerous large-scale, long-term experiments across the province. It outlines the program's history, funding, and key accomplishments, including the operational feasibility and varied environmental impacts of alternatives to clearcutting, and concludes by offering lessons learned for future large-scale forestry research endeavors and reflecting on the challenges of translating research into widespread changes in forestry practices.

This document is a detailed inventory of numerous forestry research projects across British Columbia. It systematically catalogues various long-term studies examining different silvicultural systems, which are methods for managing forest growth and harvesting timber. The document is structured geographically, listing trials in the Southern Interior, Northern Interior, and Coast regions, as well as smaller, province-wide trials, university research forests, demonstration areas, and operational case studies. For each listed project, the document typically provides information such as the establishment year, location, ecological zone, tested silvicultural systems (like clearcutting, shelterwood, and group selection), trial objectives (e.g., impacts on regeneration, wildlife, or disease), and often a list of associated publications and contact information, highlighting the extensive research network in the province.

This case study details a research project investigating alternative silvicultural systems to clearcutting in the steep-sloped old-growth forests of the Queen Charlotte Islands (now Haida Gwaii). The study, initiated in 1992, compared the effects of single-tree selection, two levels of group selection, and clearcutting on regeneration (both natural and planted) and residual stand characteristics over a seven-year period. Key findings address the effectiveness of these methods in promoting the regeneration of western hemlock, Sitka spruce, and western redcedar, as well as the impact on residual tree damage and browsing pressure from Sitka black-tailed deer, ultimately aiming to inform sustainable forest management practices in this sensitive ecosystem.